While skibereen are usually born in large groups, What-The-Dickens hatches alone in a tuna can, not knowing any language, or even what he is. As he sets out to find himself, he meets a cat, a Bengal tiger, a family of birds and an old woman. Then he finally meets Pepper, another skibereen, who teaches him the most basic facts about their kind-- one, that they are tooth fairies and two, that they are never seen. Against her better judgment she takes What-The-Dickens back to her colony. He gets a less than warm welcome, but learns more about his kind and their part in bringing wishes to humans.
I have very mixed feelings about this book. The story of the skibereen is delightful. I wish I had seen more about the various colonies and even leaned what happens to Pepper and What-The-Dickens after the book ends (I think that's where a good story would have really gotten going). But the whole framing story rubbed me the wrong way. First off the ultra-religious homeschooling stereotype is annoying, and I think largely unnecessary. I also felt the frame alluding to larger twists than it provided. For example, through most of the book the appearance of Gage at just the right time to be with the children is hinted at being part of a miracle, yet nothing really comes of it in the end.
Overall, my opinion of What-The-Dickens by Gregory Maguire is lukewarm. While the main story is pleasant enough on its own, but when surrounded by the story of the Ormsbys it become strangled.
What-The-Dickens by Gregory Maguire
Published by Candlewick
What-The-Dickens by Gregory Maguire is available at Amazon.com
I reviewed What-The-Dickens from my own personal library