Printer Friendly Version

BellaOnline's Chocolate Editor

Tomato Soup Chocolate Cake

For years, friends and family have been telling me that I have to try this.

Their arguments have been: it's easy, and the soup makes the cake moist and rich as well as bringing out the taste of the chocolate.

That first one I dismissed immediately. Tripping and falling is easy. That doesn't make it worth doing.

Moist and rich and extra chocolaty, on the other hand, are definitely worth working for. A bit of salt makes chocolate taste more intense, as anyone who's made a cup of cocoa from scratch and left out the all-important sprinkle of sodium can attest. So I decided to give the chocolate-tomato combo a shot.

I started with the simplest recommended method. I bought two boxes of chocolate cake mix. One, I prepared according to the directions on the box. I mixed the contents of the other with a can of undiluted tomato soup, a teaspoon of baking soda, and a couple of eggs.

I wanted to do a blind taste test with my son, but it was impossible. I made the cakes cupcake-style, and the tomato soup ones didn't rise nearly as high as the conventional, and were darker in color to boot. Knowing, then, that we were doing so, we each tried a bite of one of the tomato cakes plain, then with a little buttercream frosting.

Actually, I was the only one who got to the frosted one. My son bailed out, and I can't say I blame him. Cake mix cakes may or not be your idea of gourmet baking, but to me the ordinary ones tasted fine, while the tomato-enhanced cupcake I attempted to finish had a rusty aftertaste. There was no perceptible difference in moisture or texture, and the chocolate flavor was if anything overwhelmed by a dull and distinctly tomato-flavored tanginess.

Well, this was cake mix. Perhaps I couldn't say I'd given it a fair test until I'd tried it with a real cake baked from actual ingredients.

My own favorite chocolate cake recipe calls for a cup of buttermilk. A can of tomato soup, uncanned, is about a cup of liquid. Seemed like a fair trade to me.

Once again, I baked two cakes. Once again, my faithful taste-tester and I tried sampled the results.

I will say that the tomato taste was more subtle in this from-scratch creation. But it was still there, bumping rudely into our attempts to enjoy the chocolate flavor like a drunk trying to take cuts in line.

The cakes were equally moist, which makes me think that anyone who is so desperate for a yummily damp chocolate cake should just find a really good recipe, use buttermilk instead of plain, and not stint on the eggs and oil. If you want an extra-chocolate taste, use more chocolate and a little less sugar.

Again, though, this might not have been a completely fair trial. My cake recipe hadn't been created with tomato soup in mind. I found one that had.

It looked decent -- lots of cocoa powder, shortening, eggs, vanilla, and of course that undiluted can of tomato soup. I assembled it with care, baked it as directed, and let it cool, then frosted it.

It was moist. So much so that when I tried to cut a slice, the thing split in half as if I'd hit an invisible fault line. The crumb was wonderful, as was the color.

But still, there it was: that faint, metallic, but definite hint of tomato.

I threw the rest of the piece in the trash, cut myself a generous slice of what was left of the just plain chocolate cake I'd baked as a control to compare the tomato stuff to, and settled down to thoroughly enjoy the real thing.

Chocolate Site @ BellaOnline
View This Article in Regular Layout

Content copyright © 2013 by Deborah Markus. All rights reserved.
This content was written by Deborah Markus. If you wish to use this content in any manner, you need written permission. Contact Michelle Matile for details.

| About BellaOnline | Privacy Policy | Advertising | Become an Editor |
Website copyright © 2013 Minerva WebWorks LLC. All rights reserved.

BellaOnline Editor