logo
g Text Version
Beauty & Self
Books & Music
Career
Computers
Education
Family
Food & Wine
Health & Fitness
Hobbies & Crafts
Home & Garden
Money
News & Politics
Relationships
Religion & Spirituality
Sports
Travel & Culture
TV & Movies

dailyclick
Bored? Games!
Nutrition
Postcards
Take a Quiz
Rate My Photo

new
Bible Basics
Houseplants
Romance Movies
Creativity
Family Travel
Southwest USA
Irish Culture


dailyclick
All times in EST

Full Schedule
g
g Civil Rights Site

BellaOnline's Civil Rights Editor

g

Stem Cell Research the New Survival Lottery?

Guest Author - Sylvia Cochran

John Harris once proposed an experiment of thought entitled The Survival Lottery (1). The concept was quite simple: each person was assigned a number tied to the genetic makeup of her or his organs. When it could be shown that two or more lives would be saved by the death of a number’s carrier, that person was expected to surrender her or his life in order to save the two or more people.

Quite obviously the presupposition is a Utopia: there is a complete lack of corruptibility of the system; nobody is exempt from participation; everyone will participate as indicated. Those who generally would have advocated the idea that “the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few” (to paraphrase Spock) find that agreement with a forced or enforced mode of saving lives appears to be unpalatable. After all, the person who is killed so that the two or more might live on is just as valuable as the people whose death is temporarily postponed. Thus, is it truly acceptable to trade one life for another? Or, in the alternative, is this akin the NAZI practice of allocating value to life, thus creating the doctrine of worthy and unworthy life?

Stem cell research presents similar challenges to those who accept a fetus as a living being. For those who regard it as a wad of tissue or mass of cells do not suffer the conflicting emotions associated with the killing of a viable fetus in order to save the lives of those already walking the earth or the generations that are still to come.

Yet even if you do not want to get bogged down in the philosophical mire that is the theorem of the Survival Lottery, the fact that the United States Constitution does not give Congress the right to allocate any funding for scientific research makes quick work of the battle over stem cell research. Article I, Section 8 is quite clear in its limitation of Congress’ powers.

It is somewhat staggering to consider that the heated debate that is taking place over stem cell research is being sacrificed at the altar that is the separation of church and state or lost at the splitting of hairs that seeks to determine when life begins; instead, the answer is oh so simple and rather short: the federal government has no business doing business with stem cell research. Who would have thought that an ethical dilemma could be resolved that easily?


(1) Harris, John (1975). "The survival lottery." Philosophy, 50: 81-87.

This site needs an editor - click to learn more!

Add Stem+Cell+Research+the+New+Survival+Lottery%3F to Twitter Add Stem+Cell+Research+the+New+Survival+Lottery%3F to Facebook Add Stem+Cell+Research+the+New+Survival+Lottery%3F to MySpace Add Stem+Cell+Research+the+New+Survival+Lottery%3F to Del.icio.us Digg Stem+Cell+Research+the+New+Survival+Lottery%3F Add Stem+Cell+Research+the+New+Survival+Lottery%3F to Yahoo My Web Add Stem+Cell+Research+the+New+Survival+Lottery%3F to Google Bookmarks Add Stem+Cell+Research+the+New+Survival+Lottery%3F to Stumbleupon Add Stem+Cell+Research+the+New+Survival+Lottery%3F to Reddit




RSS | Related Articles | Editor's Picks Articles | Top Ten Articles | Previous Features | Site Map


For FREE email updates, subscribe to the Civil Rights Newsletter


Past Issues


print
Printer Friendly
bookmark
Bookmark
tell friend
Tell a Friend
forum
Forum
email
Email Editor


Content copyright © 2014 by Sylvia Cochran. All rights reserved.
This content was written by Sylvia Cochran. If you wish to use this content in any manner, you need written permission. Contact BellaOnline Administration for details.

g


g features
Opportunities of the US civil rights struggles

How should black Americans treat each other

Graca Simbine Machel Mandela, a humanitarian

Archives | Site Map

forum
Forum
email
Contact

Past Issues
memberscenter


vote
Poetry
Daily
Weekly
Monthly
Less than Monthly



BellaOnline on Facebook
g


| About BellaOnline | Privacy Policy | Advertising | Become an Editor |
Website copyright © 2014 Minerva WebWorks LLC. All rights reserved.


BellaOnline Editor