BOOK REVIEW - You Can’t Take a Balloon ...

BOOK REVIEW - You Can’t Take a Balloon ...
You Can’t Take a Balloon Into the Metropolitan Museum, a lavishly illustrated comic book style children’s book by Jacqueline Preiss Weitzman and Robin Preiss Glasser, tells the tale of a young girl’s visit to the museum while her balloon traverses the streets of New York City.

As the girl and her grandmother enter the Met, a security guard stops them at the door. He won’t let them in with a big yellow balloon. The girl looks at him sadly, hoping to change his mind. But rules are rules.

So he takes her balloon and ties it to the staircase railing, where she can pick it up when she is ready to leave. Just after the girl and her grandmother walk through the front door, a bird comes along and unties it! The panicked security guard begins to chase after it.

The balloon’s adventure parallels the girl’s museum visit on page after page. Real photos of masterpieces from the Met’s permanent collection are sprinkled throughout the tale, which are mimicked in the characters’ actions throughout the city.

As the girl explores the museum, the security guard slides across the ice skating rink at Rockefeller Center, crashes a wedding, and runs across the stage in the middle of an opera. As he chases the balloon, he picks up people along the way. Each scenario is complimented by a similar scene in a real painting or artifact.

Each page is magnificently illustrated with highly detailed panels. There is so much going on, children will see something different every time they open this book. Some of illustrations are full color, but most are black and white with important details fleshed out in color.

The book fails in one important respect. It does nothing to educate the young reader about the pieces of art included in the book. It would have been nice to have the artwork explained a little more. There is no narrative about the paintings and sculptures at all.

In fact, the only place the art is even mentioned is in a list in the back of the book, which only contains minimal information about the work – namely the artist, title, and donor. It is a missed opportunity not to include more context and art history.

Overall, the book is a fun read (even though there are no words!) and children will be amused by the antics of the balloon and the security guard. The photos of the art blend in very well with the illustrations – in some cases, a little too well. It will probably be up to an adult to point out the similarities between the storyline and the work of art highlighted on the page.





You Should Also Read:
BOOK REVIEW -- Maisy Goes to the Museum
BOOK REVIEW -- Fancy Nancy at the Museum
BOOK REVIEW -- Behind the Museum Door

RSS
Related Articles
Editor's Picks Articles
Top Ten Articles
Previous Features
Site Map







Content copyright © 2019 by Kim Kenney. All rights reserved.
This content was written by Kim Kenney. If you wish to use this content in any manner, you need written permission. Contact Kim Kenney for details.